Dear Denise – Your HR Agony Aunt | Edition 13: Employment Rights Act – Unfair Dismissal Changes
Date Posted: 19 Nov, 2026

If an employee is bringing an unfair dismissal claim, currently employers have two years to decide their suitability, however, this will change on 1st January 2027, which will strengthen unfair dismissal law under the Employment Rights Act 2025.
This month’s Dear Denise – HR Agony Aunt from BeyondHR looks at how employers should prepare for the upcoming changes in January 2027. Denise Donnelly, Senior HR Consultant with over 20 years’ experience, gives her insights on the responsibilities as an employer to follow the strengthened regulations and what steps can be taken to avoid an unfair dismissal claim.
Dear Denise,
One of our former employees, who has worked at our company for four months, has been underperforming and we are considering dismissing them in the near future.
What steps must we take in this situation, and what will the outcome be?
Business Owner, Paisley
Dear Business Owner,
It’s understandable that the upcoming changes to unfair dismissal rights has made you consider how to approach this employee’s performance.
When an employee in your organisation has poor performance, it’s important that you conduct a fair process before officially dismissing the employee to prevent an unfair dismissal claim from them.
Start With The Change In Law
At the moment, employees generally need two years’ service before they can bring an ordinary unfair dismissal claim. From 1st January 2027 with the reforms to the Employment Rights Act 2025, this qualifying period will reduce to 6 months.
This means employers will have a much shorter timeframe to identify and address concerns if an employee is underperforming. Employers should now follow the correct process to fairly dismiss an employee.
Speak With The Employee Who Is Underperforming
Plan a private meeting with the employee to discuss your concerns about their performance and give them the opportunity to respond.
Clearly explain your concerns and keep a written record of the discussion. This will give you the opportunity to seek more information on why the employee is underperforming and depending on the reasons, you might decide that additional support, training or another sanction is more appropriate than dismissal at this stage.
Regular feedback and review meetings can be used to determine whether there have been improvements made.
Open An Investigation
Gather and review any relevant evidence of the employee’s poor performance, for example inconsistent results, not meeting targets, absence or timekeeping issues.
It’s important to keep a written record of evidence gathered and discussions. If the matter results in dismissal, this can help demonstrate the reasons behind the dismissal and that a fair process was followed.
Update Your Policies
Prioritise keeping any employee handbooks updated to ensure they reflect current legislation and ensure employees are aware of what steps should be taken to prevent an unfair dismissal claim by the employee.
It’s important not to wait until the employee is coming to the end of their probationary period to raise concerns.
In light of this, you may also want to consider introducing an earlier probation period for employees as a 6 month probation review would mean they have already reached the qualifying period for ordinary unfair dismissal. Employees who reach six months of continuous service on or after 1st January 2027 gains this protection.
Making The Decision
Once you have considered the employee’s performance, the evidence gathered and any support or opportunities to improve, you will need to decide on the appropriate next step.
It is best practice to meet with the employee before making a final decision to dismiss. This gives them an opportunity to respond further to you concerns and allows you to consider any relevant information they provide.
Dismissal should not be a predetermined outcome. If, after considering all the circumstances, you decide that dismissal is appropriate, explain the reason for the decision and confirm the outcome in writing.
The employee will be invited to a disciplinary hearing in which you as the employer will explain your viable reason for dismissing them, ensuring that the decision aligns with the law. Additionally, use the evidence that was collected earlier from the written record to provide the employee with a valid reason why they are being dismissed, whether decided before or after the qualifying period of six months.
Have an HR question you’d like Denise to answer?
Send it to denise@wegobeyondhr.com for the chance to be featured in a future Dear Denise column. All submissions will remain anonymous.
For confidential advice tailored to your business, call the BeyondHR team on 0800 111 4461.



